Shade Cloth vs Row Cover: Which Fabric Does Your Garden Need?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Shade cloth and row cover look alike on the shelf: both are fabric, both go over a bed, and both promise to protect your plants. They do opposite jobs. Shade cloth blocks sun and cools a bed down. Row cover holds warmth in and keeps a cold night off the plants. Put the wrong one on at the wrong time of year and you get the exact problem you were trying to avoid: shade cloth in November shades plants that need every hour of weak fall sun, and row cover in July traps heat and cooks lettuce.

November is the month when the swap matters most. Summer beds come out of the shade, fall beds go under cover, and the fabric you reach for decides whether your greens keep growing or stall. This guide compares the two fabrics side by side, works out the fabric math for a standard 4 by 8 foot bed, and ends with a plain verdict for each situation.

Shade cloth vs row cover at a glance

Shade cloth Row cover
Material Knitted polyethylene mesh Spun-bonded polypropylene fabric
How it is rated Percent of light blocked: 30, 40, or 50 percent Weight in ounces per square yard: about 0.5 oz light, 1.0 to 1.5 oz medium
Light Blocks 30 to 50 percent of sunlight Lets through 70 to 90 percent of light
Temperature effect Cools leaves and soil on hot days Holds 2 to 6 degrees of warmth on cold nights
Best season Late spring through summer Fall through early spring
Support Posts, hoops, or a frame held above the plants Hoops, or laid right on the plants
Also blocks Some wind and hard rain Light frost, some insects, and wind
Take it off When the heat passes, or in fall On warm days, or plants overheat

The table shows the split in one line each: shade cloth takes light away, row cover keeps heat in. Everything else in this guide follows from that split. If you want a deeper roundup of shade cloth products before buying, see our guide to the best shade cloth for vegetable gardens, and for frost protection in general, see our guide to how to protect raised beds from frost.

Shade cloth: what it does well

Shade cloth earns its place in hot weather. A 30 percent cloth cuts about a third of the sunlight, which is enough to stop lettuce from bolting and peppers from getting sunscald, without starving the plants of light. A 40 percent cloth suits most vegetables in a hot summer, and a 50 percent cloth fits very hot spots, or crops that prefer shade, such as lettuce in July and August. The cloth also drops the temperature around the leaves: on a hot afternoon, the air under shade cloth can run about 10 to 15 degrees cooler than the open sun, which is a typical range from extension guidance, not a lab measurement, and it varies with wind and humidity.

Shade cloth needs a frame. It has to sit above the plants on posts, hoops, or a simple frame, with air moving underneath. Cloth laid right on the leaves traps heat and flattens the plants, which defeats the purpose. A frame also lets you pull the cloth back on cloudy days, so the plants get full light when the sun is weak. Knitted cloth lasts longer than woven cloth outdoors, because the knit stretches instead of tearing at the edges, and it can be cut without unraveling.

Dark shade cloth stretched over hoops above a raised vegetable bed in bright sun

Pros of shade cloth

It cools the bed on hot days, stops sunscald on peppers and tomatoes, slows bolting in lettuce and herbs, and lasts several seasons when stored dry. It also breaks hard rain into a gentler fall, which keeps soil from compacting.

Cons of shade cloth

It gives no frost protection, it shades plants that need full sun if left on too long, and it needs a frame, which adds cost and setup time. In a cool or cloudy climate it can do more harm than good, because the plants lose light they needed.

Row cover: what it does well

Row cover earns its place in cold weather. Light row cover, about 0.5 ounces per square yard, typically adds about 2 to 4 degrees of frost protection, which is enough to carry lettuce and greens through a light frost. Medium row cover, about 1.0 to 1.5 ounces per square yard, typically adds about 4 to 6 degrees, which covers a moderate frost and stretches the fall season by weeks. These are typical ranges from extension guidance, and the real number depends on wind, soil moisture, and how well the edges are sealed.

Row cover is also the simplest fabric to use. It can rest right on the plants for low crops such as lettuce and carrots, or drape over hoops for taller plants such as broccoli and kale. It lets rain through, so the bed still gets watered, and it keeps many insects off the crop while it is on. Unlike shade cloth, it needs no frame for low plants, which is why it is the first fabric most gardeners buy.

Row cover has one habit that catches people out: it warms up fast in the sun. A bed under row cover on a sunny November afternoon can overheat, even when the morning was near freezing. Vent it or pull it back on warm days, and put it back on before dusk. A row cover left on through a warm spell can also keep pollinators away from flowering plants, so lift it while squash and cucumbers are in flower. For a direct comparison with plastic sheeting, see our guide to frost cloth vs plastic cover, and for covers sized to raised beds, see our roundup of the best frost covers for raised beds and containers.

White row cover fabric draped over hoops on a raised bed in a fall garden

Pros of row cover

It adds real frost protection, stretches the fall and spring seasons, keeps insects off the crop, lets rain through, and needs no frame for low plants. It is light, cheap, and easy to store folded in a shed.

Cons of row cover

It overheats beds on sunny days, it tears more easily than shade cloth, light weights give only a few degrees of protection, and it blocks pollinators while it is on. It also does nothing against a hard freeze: when the forecast drops well below freezing, row cover alone will not save tender plants.

A worked example: covering a 4 by 8 foot bed

Here is the fabric math for a standard 4 by 8 foot raised bed, which is 32 square feet. The plan assumes hoops 2 feet tall at the center for the row cover, and posts holding the shade cloth flat above the bed. Buy a little extra in both cases, because fabric cut short cannot be stretched and edges need to be weighted down.

For row cover over hoops, the fabric has to clear the top of the hoop and reach the ground on both sides. The bed is 4 feet wide, the hoop rises 2 feet, and the curve over the top adds about 3 feet to the straight width, so the fabric needs to be about 7 feet wide. The length runs 8 feet for the bed plus 1 foot at each end to tuck under, which is 10 feet. That gives 7 feet by 10 feet, or 70 square feet of fabric, for a 32 square foot bed. Buy a 7 by 10 foot piece, or cut it from a wider roll.

For shade cloth flat over the bed, the math is simpler. The cloth needs to cover the 4 by 8 foot bed plus about 6 inches of overhang on each side, so the plants at the edges sit in shade too. That gives 5 feet by 9 feet, or 45 square feet of cloth. Shade cloth is sold by the percent of light blocked, so pick the rating for the crop: 30 percent for lettuce and leafy greens, 40 percent for tomatoes, peppers, and most summer vegetables, and 50 percent for a very hot spot or for shade-loving crops in midsummer.

The temperature numbers to plan around are these. A light row cover typically holds about 2 to 4 degrees of warmth, and a medium row cover about 4 to 6 degrees, which is enough for a light or moderate frost but not a hard freeze. A 40 percent shade cloth typically drops the temperature around the leaves by about 10 to 15 degrees on a hot afternoon. Use those ranges as planning numbers, not promises, and check the plants on the first hot or cold day under the fabric to see how your own bed behaves.

Two raised beds side by side, one under white row cover and one under dark shade cloth

Which fabric does your garden need?

Choose shade cloth if your beds sit in full sun through a hot summer, if lettuce bolts before it sizes up, if peppers show pale sunscald patches, or if the soil dries out by noon on hot days. Choose it for the hot months, take it down when the heat passes, and store it dry so it lasts for years.

Choose row cover if frost is forecast in the next few weeks, if you want fall greens to keep growing into November, if insects are chewing your brassicas, or if you are starting seeds outdoors in early spring and need a few extra degrees. Choose it for the cold months, vent it on warm days, and take it off before a hard freeze, when only a move indoors or a heated cover will save tender plants.

If your garden needs both, buy both. Many gardeners keep shade cloth on the summer beds and row cover on the fall beds, and the two fabrics swap places as the year turns. Use your local frost dates and regional planting guidance, not your USDA hardiness zone alone, to choose planting dates, and let those same dates decide when the row cover goes on and the shade cloth comes off.

Sources & Further Reading

University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources

Cornell Cooperative Extension

North Carolina State University Extension

Leave a Comment